Friday, 14 November 2014

City of God Narrative & Influence of Western cinema/accesibility of National Cinema

City of God
 
City of God (Cidade de Deus).
This ground-level report on gang life in the slums of Rio de Janeiro exploded with thrilling and terrible force. An electrifying piece of cinema packed full of visual invention and dazzling set-pieces, it owes a debt to Martin Scorsese's Goodfellas and audaciously pays it off. Though it unfolds at an exhilarating pace and crackles with danger, the film never allows itself to become seduced by the abundant violence of favela life. Instead, it keeps its lens trained on the attendant horrors, which mount up as the narrative jumps forward in time. What is most horrifying of all is how those caught up in the violence – victims and perpetrators alike – keep getting younger and younger.
  1. City of God (Cidade de Deus)
  2. Production year: 2002
  3. Country: Rest of the world
  4. Cert (UK): 18
  5. Runtime: 135 mins
  6. Directors: Fernando Meirelles
  7. Cast: Alexandre Rodrigues, Leandro Firmino da Hora, Matheus Nachtergaele, Phelipe Haagensen
The film begins in the relative innocence of the late 60s, soon after the City of God (a real-life Rio slum, ironically named) was constructed. Rocket (Alexandre Rodrigues) is an 11-year-old at the margins of gang life. His older brother's crew are involved in petty crime, holding up trucks carrying propane gas and selling the loot to local residents. Things start getting out of control when Rocket's younger gang target the clients of a sleazy motel and the raid, intended to be bloodless, becomes a killing spree.
The film's most chilling image, revealed later on in flashback, is of the tiny Li'l Dice returning to the motel alone and gleefully slaying everyone inside. Flash-forward to the 70s and Dice, now restyled as Li'l Zé, is the most fearsome gang leader in the City of God. And yet even Zé, for all his psychotic tendencies, has a sense of order, and the favela is relatively peaceful once his reign is established. Other criminals are simply executed – or in one unforgettable instance, shot in the foot – if they cause trouble. But the peace is shakily constructed and warfare erupts on a massive scale as the film moves into the early 80s. When Zé meets his end, it's at the hand of a gang populated by nine- and 10-year-olds with designs on his drug-dealing monopoly. It's a profoundly disturbing sequence of events, but the film is still hugely enjoyable thanks to César Charlone's camerawork and the magnificent, sprawling cast of non-professional actors who were recruited from the City of God itself and adjacent slums.
Meirelles went on to direct The Constant Gardener and Blindness.

City of God

 
Absolutely everything you need to know about CITY OF GOD
Synopsis – The film is in three parts

 The story of the Tender Trio
In the City of God, one of the slums on the hills above Rio de Janeiro, Buscape (Rocket) wants to be a photographer. He runs into Ze Pequeno (Little Ze) and his armed gang of children (the Runts). He tells the stories of the City in flashback beginning in the 1960s when his brother Marreco (Goose) together with Cabeleira (Shaggy) and Alicate (Clipper) are known as The Tender Trio. They are amateur petty thieves who plan to rob a brothel, the Miami Motel. They take Dadinho (Little Dice), the 9-year-old friend of Shaggy’s brother Bene, along to act as lookout. The robbery ends in a massacre. The Trio split up. Shaggy hides in Lucia Maracana’s house. He is very attracted to her daughter Berenice. Goose meets and flirts with the wife of Paraiba (Shorty). Shorty catches them in bed together. Goose runs away and finds Bene and Little Dice hiding out in an unfinished building. Shorty buries his wife alive, the police take him away. Shaggy and Berenice hijack a car at gunpoint. The car packs up. The police shoot Shaggy. A man takes photographs of the body. Rocket is envious of his camera.

The story of Little Ze
The story moves forward to the 1970s. Rocket, still a virgin, takes photographs of his friends ‘the Groovies’ on the beach. He fancies Angelica but she has a boyfriend Thiago who has graduated from smoking dope to snorting coke. Rocket goes to the apartment where Neguinho (Blacky) sells dope. Little Dice swaggers in. He has changed his name to Little Ze. He murdered the customers at the brothel and later killed Goose. At 18 he is in the drugs business, having killed all of the other dealers in the city except Sandro Cenoura (Carrot). Bene still attempts to keep Little Ze under control advocating negotiation rather than murder. Bene meets the Groovies and admires Thiago’s style. He bleaches his hair, gets new clothes and transforms himself into a playboy. After loosing his job at the Supermarket Rocket decides to do some hold ups with his friend Barbantinho (Stringy). They board a bus planning to rob the fare collector Mane Galinha (Knockout Ned). Ned, who is against violence, advises them to study and get out of the City. They don’t go through with the robbery. Bene and Angelica are in love. They plan to leave the City and live a life of peace in the country. At Bene’s farewell party Ze is angry that his close friend is giving up the hood’s life for a woman. An argument breaks out and they struggle amongst the dancers. Blacky, aiming to kill Ze, accidentally shoots Bene. Little Ze is jealous of Knockout Ned and wants Ned’s girlfriend. His gang hold Ned down whilst Ze rapes her.

The story of Knockout Ned
Ned goes home in anguish. Ze goes to his house to kill him. His gang kill Ned’s father, uncle and brother. Carrot comes by and offers Ned a gun and Ned takes it. Although at first Ned does not want violence he and Carrot become involved in all out gang war with Ze, robbing banks and killing in order to buy bigger and better weapons. Rocket gets a job delivering newspapers, going to the newspaper offices at night where he has a friend in the photo lab. The war continues with children fighting on both sides. A boy Otto joins Carrots gang. Ned is wounded and arrested. Ze sees the TV news where Ned is being interviewed as a celebrity. He is furious that he is not seen as the boss of the city. Thiago fetches Rocket who takes pictures of Ze posing with his gang. Marina, who works for the newspaper, finds the photos. Rocket sees his photographs on the front page of the newspaper. He thinks Ze will kill him. The journalists want Rocket to take more pictures. Rocket can’t go back to the City, it’s too risky. He has nowhere to sleep. Marina takes him back to her apartment where he takes his first hot shower and has his first sexual experience. Carrot and his gang spring Ned from the hospital. There is a pitched battle between the gangs and Rocket takes pictures for the newspaper. Ned is killed. Ze tries to round up the Runts to restart his business. They shoot him, the business is theirs! Rocket takes pictures of the body. The photograph makes the front page. He is now Wilson Rodrigues, photographer.
Introduction
City of God is an example of Brazilian national cinema. It is also an international film that secured worldwide distribution through Miramax, a major distributor that has a reputation for distributing independent films, the most famous examples are films by Quentin Tarantino, and films such as The Piano and The Crying Game. Miramax is now owned by Disney. It illustrates the comparative accessibility of World Cinema, a label that previously denoted only a limited distribution in art cinemas of films made known through their success in film festivals. Its success can be examined through its relationship to mainstream cinema in terms of production values, genre and narrative. In examining its popularity, especially among film-goers between 18 and 25, it is necessary to consider how far City of God use recognisable genre features and transport them to different and more colourful locations. However recognisable these genre features might be the themes of the film and concerns of the characters are in many ways very specific to their setting.
Comparisons have been made with Goodfellas and Pulp Fiction but neither of these films actually deal with social problems or issues. The reputation gained by City of God was for much part that of a film that reveals the true facts about poverty in the slums of Rio de Janeiro and the endemic nature of the violence that accompanies it. Given the publicity it received, the nature of some of the rave reviews and the stated intention of the film-makers it can be studied as a political film with a message. At the same time it relies heavily on the artificiality of cinematic techniques and a complex narrative structure, not the realist style formerly associated with films about social deprivation (for example Sweet Sixteen). As such it enters into the debate around the form that a film’s messages should take, and whether such films should contain suggestions as to the possible origin and remedy of the social inequality they represent.

The film director
Fernando Meirelles had directed one previous film, and was a director of commercials for a Brazilian advertising agency, O2. The film was based on the novel of the same name by Paulo Lins, a long 700 page multi-character novel described as ‘Dickensian’. It uses amateur actors who were recruited from the favelas and encouraged to improvises to give the film authenticity.
Filming took place entirely in the slums. It was was financed by TV Globo, Brazil’s biggest TV channel, and 02 Filmes. The success of the film led to a TV mini-series Cidode dos Homens I City of Men set in the Dona Martela favela and featuring the same actors. An estimated 35 million viewers watched the first series. Together with co-director Katia Lund he started the organisation ‘Nos do cinema I ‘We of the Cinema. This is a workshop project for boys from the favelas. The film cost about $3m to make and has taken around $30m at the box office worldwide.

The Narrative
City of God uses narrative in a complex way, manipulating the timeframe, and using a narrator to lead the audience through the film. This kind of narrator is known as homodiegetic – he is inside the narrative narrating in the first person. The narrative doesn’t fall easily into the usual theory. There is certainly three parts to the film, but they don’t really fit Sid Field’s theory of a start, middle and end. The start after all is a sequence that actually heralds the end of the film, and apart from being a dramatic sequence that serves to engage the audience, it guarantees an understanding of the changed circumstances of the city, and makes the antics of the Tender Trio look rather tame compared with the later action.
Todorov’s theory of an equilibrium, followed by a disequilibrium, then a new equilibrium could be applied. The original equilibrium of the tame amateur gangsterism of the Tender Trio is disrupted by the rapid escalation of violence that follows the Miami Hotel raid and the jump forward in time to the 70s where we see a grown up Lil Ze, and the true events of the night at the Miami Hotel are shown. This then proceeds to the new equilibrium at the end where we see Lil Ze being assinated by the Runts – a new generation of kids re-claiming the streets, except that instead of being shown playing football they’re planning who they’re going to kill off next!
Roland Barthes theories of action and enigma codes can easily be applied, remember that Barthes said that there are two ways of creating suspense in narrative, the first caused by unanswered questions, the second by the anticipation of an action’s resolution – there are numerous examples of actions which lead to a re-action such as:
  • The Tender Trio’s raid on the Miami Hotel in a desire to become more serious gangsters leads to the deaths of Shaggy and Goose and eventually reveals Lil Ze’s true character.
  • Bene’s decision to leave the gangster’s life leads to his death.
  • Ned’s decision to seek revenge on his brother’s death leads to him joining Carrot’s gang and his eventual death.
  • The killing of the security guard, who turns out to be Otto’s father, also leads to Ned’s death.
  • The desire for Lil Ze to have his picture taken leads to them fetching Rocket, whose photos are published and he not only gets a jobs as a photographer but loses his virginity (at last) to Marina
The are also numerous narrative enigma – unanswered questions – that mislead the audience.
  • The opening sequence is that of a relaxed street party which leads to a confrontation, and when re-played at the end of the film turns into a massacre.
  • The Miami Hotel raid massacre eventually turns out to be Lil Ze’s first act of mass violence.
  • Bene’s meeting with Thiago leads to the bike race, which we assume will end in violence, but actually ends in Bene buying trainers and clothes and getting a more modern image.
  • Rocket and Stringy’s abortive attempt to hold up a car, and coming across a kindly driver who befriends them, leads to the scene where the police find a body by the roadside, and we assume that Rocket and Stringy have succumbed to violence and killed the driver, but then the car drives past with Rocket and Stringy still inside.
We can also apply Claude Levi-Strauss’ theory of binary opposites – the idea that the constant creation of conflict/opposition propels narrative – to the film. Remember that these opposites can be anything, some examples in City of God are:
  • The contrast between the city as a glamorous tourist destination and the povert and deprivation in the slums that surround it.
  • The portrayal of the City of God in the 60s, the bright lighting and wide open spaces, and the dark, grey closed in slum at the end.
  • The conflict between the police and the gangsters.
  • The conflict between honesty and dishonesty.
  • The conflict between the values of the women – who invariably want their men to settle down and lead a ‘normal’ life, and the men, who are invariably looking for reasons not to!
  • The opposites of the camera and the gun, which is one of the main themes of the film.
Our old friend Propp can’t be left out here, but it is more difficult to apply to City of God than Sweet Sixteen. Rocket is obviously the hero, and Ze the villain. Marina could be the helper, or even fairy godmother. Bene could be the donor, because it’s through him that Rocket aquires the camera. Maybe Ned is a false hero? As for the functions of the character, there are numerous examples, but they don’t appear in the same order that Propp suggests!
The film also employs numerous diegetic narrative devices to help us along, such as newspaper headlines, photographs, TV interviews and music:
  • Newspaper headlines tell us what Shorty did to his wife ‘Man buries wife alive in City of God’ and at the nd ‘The Self Styled Boss of the City of God is Dead’
  • Rockets photographs taken on the beach act as a signifier of his feelings for Angelica and his relationship with the gang of Groovies. Later his photos earn him his passage out of the slum.
  • The TV interview with Ned – which is seen by Rocket and Lil Ze and acts as a trigger for Ze to send for Rocket to show who’s the real boss.
  • Bene dancing to James Brown’s ‘Sex Machine’ signifies his new found image, and ‘Kung Fu Fighting’ being played at Bene’s farewell is ironic considering what happens there.
The film also uses ‘Montage editing’ to powerful effect. Montage editing is the way shots are put together to clash with each other and produce shocks, rather than smooth continuity. Think of the very first shots you see, the knife being sharpened on a stone, followed by a black screen, repeated 5 times in quick succession. Compare that with the dreamy opening sequence of Sweet Sixteen. The shots of the guitar playing and the samba rhythm then contrast with shots of a nervous looking chicken watching his mates having their neck sliced and his eventual escape.
In contrast a different kind of editing is used in ‘The Story of the Apartment’ where we are placed as a kind of ‘voyeur’ or spectator watching what goes on and how the apartment changes over time, all from a wide angle viewpoint and deep focus which give an exaggerated perspective with characters appearing large in the foreground, small in the background. The story is told with a series of dissolves where people appear, disappear and reappear in different parts of the room. The walls change colour, the lighting gets darker and darker, and the apartment becomes more and more scruffy. The apartment starts off looking like someone’s home, and ends up looking like a crack den.  Initially there is a woman, Dona Zelia, whos seems to occupy the apartment as a drug dealer and prostitute, but in time she disappears with no explanation, like all the other women in the film.  The impact of Mise-en-Scene is profound here, with the film makers using the changes in settings as a signifier of the descent of it’s occupants deeper and deeper into squalor.
Split screen is used to show two episodes at the same time, and many sequences are shown twice changing our perception or filling in missing information, for example:
  • The image that we see at the beginning of Rocket behind the grill only becomes when at the end he is shown taking the shots of Ze bribing the police through the grilled window.
  • The chicken chase at the beginning is firstly seen as rather comical, but the second time it leads to a massacre.
  • After the scene of Bene telling Ze he’s leaving we see an ols sepia photograph of them when they were kids together.
  • The Miami Hotel raid is shown twice, once when the Tender Trio escape farcically in a stolen car that they can’t drive and eventually crash into shorty’s bar, then late when Ze shoots at the window because he’s bored before cold-bloodedly killing all the customers.
  • Goose finding Lil Dice and bene in the construction site is replayed a second toime showing Goose being shot.
  • The bank shoot out where Ned kills the bank worker is seen again showing Otto present, leading to his revenge killing of Ned after he joins the gang.


 

Pans Labyrinth Sweeded

Wednesday, 12 November 2014

Representation & Authorship: Pan's meaning and style/yonic & phallic (the film is about menstration???)

READ THIS FIRST: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/poptheology/2012/05/pans-labyrinth/

"In trying to do that, I chose that war because it was a household war. People that shared beds, shared dining tables and shared lives ultimately killed each other. I tried to use an orphanage as the classic haunted building of gothic romance and use the ghost story to prove the same thing that I wanted to prove in Pan's Labyrinth, that is the only real monsters are human. And the only thing you have to be afraid of is people, not creatures, not ghosts"





Interview: http://www.theguardian.com/film/2006/nov/21/guardianinterviewsatbfisouthbank

Sketches: http://www.theguardian.com/film/flash/page/0,,1949730,00.html

http://seriousfilm.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/20-pans-labyrinth-details-you-may-have.html

Friday, November 15, 2013


20 Pan's Labyrinth Details You May Have Missed


Pan's Labyrinth is one of those rare films where the imagery is so dense that you keep making discoveries no matter how often you return to it. I have lost count of how many times I have watched Guillermo del Toro's masterpiece since 2006, and I have yet to have get through a viewing without spotting some new element. Here are just some of the details I didn't notice until after several viewings:

1. Empty Sockets
There is an early bit of foreshadowing when Ofelia is on her way to the mill for the first time where she returns the eye to its place on a stone figure. The motif of placing eyeballs into sockets will repeat later with the Pale Man.

2.  Hidden Fauns
The image of the Faun is scattered throughout the film. In this shot, for example, a faun can be spotted carved into the banister.

3. Gears
The giant gears in the background of Captain Vidal’s lair deliberately echo the gears of his prized watch that was left to him by his father.

4. Birthmark
Ofelia has a birthmark on her shoulder, which is said to be proof of her royal identity. At the start of the film the moon can be seen to be a crescent that matches the birthmark. At the film’s end the moon is full, perhaps signifying her complete transformation to her royal identity.

5. Color Coding
Pan's Labyrinth color codes the separate worlds of the film. Blue for reality. Red/Gold for fantasy. Green for the world of the Faun. As the boundaries between the worlds break down so too do the colors bleed from one world to another.

6. A Nod to Alice
The film is peppered with references to film and literature. The design of Ofelia’s green dress, for example, is a clear tribute to Alice in Wonderland.
7. Reverse Aging
As the film progresses the faun gets younger and healthier looking. He sheds moss and dirt. His hair goes from white to blond. His teeth straighten and whiten. His eyes become unclouded and his movements go from jerky to smooth. Del Toro explained that it means more in the end for Ofelia to refuse the Faun’s request if she does so when the Faun is at his most appealing.
8. Right Next Door
The film frequently uses vertical wipes to transfer between scenes. It's a subtle way to suggest the real world and the fantasy world exist closely alongside one another

9. Tree of Life
The film’s central image of the tree with the split trunk is loaded with symbolic weight. Not only do the curved trunks bring to mind the twisted horns of the Faun but it also resembles the shape of fallopian tubes in one of the film’s many examples of birth imagery.
10. Mirror Images
Elements of the fantasy world and real world mirror each other throughout the film. Examples include:
  • In both worlds a key is an object of importance
  • A hidden blade pays a role in both reality and fantasy worlds
  • Mercedes has a secret hole in the floor. Ofelia later creates a hole in the floor using magic.
  • Ofelia is given a living mandrake root by the Faun to heal her mother. Earlier Mercedes is glimpsed chopping a mandrake root in the kitchen.
11. Captain Vidal = The Pale Man
Speaking of mirroring, the film’s most famous monster is so terrifying in its own right that most viewers miss the many parallels between the Pale Man sequence and the dinner scene with Captain Vidal that immediately precedes it. Both scenes are similarly framed with the villains at the head of a long banquet table with their backs to a fire place.

12. Why So Hungry?
Many viewers wonder why Ofelia is so foolish as to disobey the Faun’s instructions and wake the monster by eating the grapes. Beside the fact that disobedience in the face of authority is one of Pan’s central themes, recall that Ofelia was sent to bed with dinner the night before and may have gone a full day without eating at this point. Also keep in mind that Ofelia has just been proven right when she trusted her own judgment and ignored advice about which door hid the knife.

13. Lies Everywhere
The Fairies weren't the only ones to mislead Ofelia about which door hides the blade. The Faun’s book also suggests the incorrect middle door. The door also plays on the same theme of deceptive visuals as the increasing beauty of the Faun. The beautiful door is the false choice. The shabby, broken down door hides the treasure.
14. 1 Out Of 3 Ain’t Bad
Ofelia returns to her Kingdom at the film’s end despite failing two out of three tests put to her in the film. She wakes the Pale Man and refuses to turn over her brother to the Faun. The only test she passes is retrieving the key from the toad.
15. Backbone Reunion
The young stars of del Toro’s The Devil’s Backbone have a brief cameo as rebel fighters.

16. Wings of Fire
Captain Vidal is positioned in front of the fireplace in such a way as to create the impression of fiery wings.
17. The Unexplained Chalk

Throughout most of the film all Ofelia’s actions in the "real" world have plausible, non-magical explanations. It’s not until her escape from the attic at the film's end that there is an action that can only be explained by magic. Where did that chalk come from if not the Faun?

18.  The Immortality Rose
The rose from Ofelia's bedtime story makes a return appearance in the pattern of Ofelia’s gown in the film’s final scene.
19. Tailor Tales
It is briefly mentioned that Ofelia’s murdered father was a tailor. This may explain why Ofelia is such a devoted fan of fairy tales. Tailors and cobblers were traditionally the tellers of fairy tales which is why so many have tailors and cobblers as central characters.
20. Fairies Resurrected
The two fairies killed by the Pale Man are seen alive again in the final scene. If we are taking the fantasy sequences literally this lends credence to the theory that the tests may have been faked and were more about how Ofelia behaved during the tests than about the supposed goals. 


Genre starter clips



How accessible are these examples of World Cinema by using GENRE and NARRATIVE conventions

How do they use these conventions to justify them as National Cinema?

Who are the distributors - are they independent or are they owned by mainstream parents companies and what links can you find to the types of US films they sell? Any overlap with the influences/references?

2.2 Representation

Pan's Labyrinth
What do the characters represent in relation to Spainish Culture?


How is the military and the church represented?


What do the occultic creatures/monsters represent?


How is youth & innocence represented through Ofelia's character - what purpose and function (see context)?
 

How is gender representation in the film - is Pan's a feminist film?


Discuss the relationship between masculinity and Facism. What is it saying?


How does the film represent Spain and it's National Identity compared to other films (see below Spirit of the Beehive etc)? Is this National Cinema (see director interview)


How would these representations of people and nation be recieved by the National Audience - article/critical reviews?













La Haine
How are the police represented in relation to what we know about the Prime Minister and President of France at this time?



Highlight the differences in the representation of Central Paris and the Slums (Baloon) - what is the director trying to draw attention to or say?


How does France in this film represent the values of Liberty, Equality and Fraternity - which scenes back this up?


How in Vince introduced - what is notable about his relationship with American Cultural references (films, music etc) and his relationship with his family?


How is Hubert intriduced - what does his room and relationship with family reveal about him?
Out of the 3 how is he represented as a man, and an ethnic French-man?


City of God








What role do men and women play in this text?


How important is the representation of 'family' or 'brotherhood' to the cause/effect in the narrative - what does it take to 'come of age' in this film and become a man?
 

What contextual reasons are there for the gangs - are father figures relevant?


How central to the narrative are women in this film? Do they appear rather than act, or influence rather than effect?


What power do women have in the film to influence, what lessons/consequences are there in the narrative and what is the film therefore saying about Brazilian culture?


Does Mulvey's Male Gaze approach apply to this film - why and what does this suggest about the domestic audience for this film?

What have the reviews suggested about the representation of women and youth in this film - are there any differenecs from how it would be received and the messages understood by it's domestic audience?


How is poverty represented - what is the film 'saying' about the residents of the Favela communities?



Phallic or yonic imagery, examples of psychoanalysis here with parental role models or birth?



How is Brasil's National Identity represented in CoG - does it qualifiy as Nationa Cinema?





2.1 Critical Thinking Skills Assessment


What is your thesis (answer or argument)?

What skills do you need to demonstrate?

How do the films comparable & how do they contrast Narrative Techniques, Structure, Theories - use of these to create meaning?

How does the context (history, cultural myths, beliefs, identity) of Spain and France create meaning through the Narrative or the Themes it raises?

What other MACRO can you apply to the above?

Why are audiences important, why is this plural and what concept of foreign cinema are we linking this to?

How are we positioned in the narrative as a spectator that creates meaning?

Why are cultural myths so important to this question?




How do we prepare for a exam that requires argument, comparison and critical thinking backed up with relevant points and references to examples?

A written debate

How are the message, myths & ideas explored in the Narrative of La Haine & Pans Labrynth different?

How do the 2 films differ in their approach to Genre to express the culture's ideas, myths and history?

How do the 2 films differ in their Themes and in expressing the culture's ideas and history?

How do the 2 films differ in their use of Style to express the culture's ideas, myths and history?

How does the Narrative position the viewer in the 2 films and how is this used to create contrasting messages/ideas?

What Narrative techniques/theories are used, how are they used differently to tell the country's story?

How important is Narrative of the films in expressing the messages, myths and ideas of the country?

To what extent are the Narratives expressing National Cinema?

Checklist:
Debate need to include:
Argument/Opinion that is justified/explained
Overlaps with other Macro
Comparing the differences between the films use of narrative or:
Differences in messages & values
Linked to Context of Country (myths, culture etc)

Now:
Thinking time
Argue against theirs or justify their argument
Comparing the differences between the films use of narrative or:
Differences in messages & values
Linked to Context of Country (myths, culture etc)

Next:
Synthesis (Snickers)
5 min: read both
5 min: list of points (use checklist - what is missing?)
5 min: thinking how to 'Synthesis': reshape/review your argument reconciling strongest of both

Apply to demonstrate your critical thinking & application of context & macro

Write up your Thesis - not a trained exam response to a expected question but application of understanding.

Class activity: Create the essay (Narrative)
Using the 3 paragraph from each question
Video Essay critical comparison of the films with image examples to back up points

Narrative plays a significant role in the construction of message and values. To what extent is this evident in Amelie & Pans Labrynth?

Rewrite the question. What is it asking? Why will the films differ?

Martin's response on Style
How do the 2 films differ in their use of Style to express the culture's ideas, myths and history?

The two films express the aspects of their culture very differently through their use of style. I feel that they differ as one uses style to create an accurate representation of the country whilst the other does its best to romanticise its country and present it in a positive somewhat untruthful way. Pans Labrinth gives a gritty, truthful representation of 1940s Spain through the dark lighting and sombre themes of death and facism within the film. The film follows Spanish beliefs closely as through Ofelias sacrifice led to her being reunited with her father once she was dead, therefore strongly reinforcing the countries catholic and christian beliefs. 3,3Amelie however does not give such an accurate representation of its country, all areas shot in the film are clean and look as if they would be pleasant to visit. This as well as the happy almost cartoon colour grading gives a surreal and overly positive feel to the film. (2)This follows with what the condition of france actually was in the time surrounding the films production as Paris had recently had many issues such as the riots and frequent problems with racism. None of these issues are addressed in the film especially the racial aspect as not a single black character is included within the film. This shows that one of the films uses style to try and get across a truthful dark view of the country at the time and accurately represent its history and struggles whilst one uses it simply as an "auteurs touch" or to market Paris as an attractive, clean and friendly place.
Martin Stewart

The setting in Amelie is not portrayed in a truthful way, which adds to the message that the country didn't feel comfortable with their true identity and wanted people to believe it was a positive place to visit in order to gain a good reputation. The film director of Amelie is misleading the viewers into believing an untrue representation of France. On the other hand, in Pans Labyrinth the audience is seeing a young child being psychologically beaten by the Spanish Civil war, which is truthfully sticking to the history of Spain, reinforcing the idea that war shouldn't exist.

New Points
Myths - City of Love (Paris)
Pans Labrinth relies heavily on narrative rather than simply style to present ideas, myths and history
Pans Labrinth shows war ruins lives, war is bad, consequences of facism
Amelie shows the importance of helping each other, the joys of innocence, the importance of love and not being alone/isolated

Synthesised Answer
The two films express the aspects of their culture very differently through their use of style. I feel that they differ as one uses style to create an accurate representation of the country whilst the other does its best to romanticise its country and present it in a positive somewhat untruthful way. Pans Labrinth gives a gritty, truthful representation of 1940s Spain through the dark lighting and sombre themes of death and facism within the film. The film follows Spanish beliefs closely as Ofelias sacrifice led to her being reunited with her father once she was dead, therefore strongly reinforcing the countries catholic and christian beliefs. the film also shows the impact of war on young children, and reinforces the idea that children cannot deal with adult themes. Amelie however does not give such an accurate representation of its country, all areas shot in the film are clean and look as if they would be pleasant to visit. This as well as the happy almost cartoon colour grading gives a surreal and overly positive feel to the film. This overly happy representation of france ties in perfectly with the idea that Paris is the city of love, this is reinforced also through the narrative as the film has Amelie playing cupid. Through this an untrue representation of France is given to the audience of the film.  During the time surrounding the films production Paris had recently had many issues such as the riots and frequent problems with racism. None of these issues are addressed in the film especially the racial aspect as not a single black character is included within the film. I feel that this unrealistic view is given as the country didn't feel comfortable with their true identity and therefore didn't want the whole world to see the true issues that they face. This shows that one of the films uses style to try and get across a truthful dark view of the country at the time and accurately represent its history and struggles whilst one uses it simply as an "auteurs touch" or to market Paris as an attractive, clean and friendly place to the rest of the world.


Rebecca's Post on genre
Argument: Genre plays an important role in the success of a foreign film as it is key to how the different audiences are drawn into watching the films, for example its horror genre that will use predicted horror conventions which certain audiences know and love, who will therefore have an attraction to the film.

Genre appeals to certain audiences as it allows us to pick the aspects that we like to watch. e.g. someone may prefer the conventions of a Romance film and therefore be more likely to see future romance films with an expectation as to what they will be like. We can recognise the genre through our previous experiences. 

Horror / Fantasy - conform with aspects of Pan's Labyrinth. The film was successful as Lord of The Rings was also of the fantasy genre and had a large audience that went to see the films which brought in a vast amount of money.

Genre also contributes to success on the basis it is easy to understand because it is the same all over the world; genre breaks films into different categories, providing us with the ability to sift through the films and select the ones we would most like to watch.

Genre is similar to Narrative e.g. Fairytale characters (Propp).

It is not about showing the culture of the country, it is about being successful to audiences and making money. This is part of the reasoning as to why both Pan's Labyrinth and Amelie have a strong use of style to appeal to different audiences. For example, in Pan's Labyrinth, fantasy conventions are conveyed through the use of magical realism. Romantic conventions and the myth of Paris being the city of love is demonstrated through Amelie in the form of French New Wave and Cinema Du Look, linking to the phrase "style over substance".



Amelie – Romantic Comedy

-       Amelie uses the genre of romantic comedy to appeal worldwide to any audiences, it is a stereotype of the genre of romantic comedy that the film will follow the classic Hollywood narrative making it a presumption of any going to see it in other films that they will easily be able to follow the narrative as it is a convention of the genre
-       Uses a heterosexual relationship within the romance to make it acceptable worldwide

 Pans Labyrinth – Fantasy

-       Pans Labyrinth uses the fantasy genre as it is one that is accepted worldwide and can be viewed and understood by all audiences
-       Offers an opportunity for people to watch the film as a serious contextually strong piece of national cinema or as simply a fantasy from Ofelia’s point of view allowing it to be an international bestseller
-       The use of fantasy allows the messages of the film to be portrayed through the innocent eyes of a child, without the use of fantasy Ofelia would be facing up to real people rather than the monsters that she and we as the viewer sees
-       Allows us through the use of a fantasy genre to see how the war scars the children of Spain at the time

Thursday, 16 October 2014

1.7 Genre

Genre plays a significant role in the construction of message and values. To what extent is this evident in La Haine & Pans Labyrinth/City of God?











Key Thought: Which of these films did well internationally, and why do you think that is?

Starter: What is the difference in how Pans is sold to an English speaking audience compared to it's domestic market?








Some notes

- Marketing affected by genre
- Fantasy well marketed internationally
- U.S trailer presents the film as slightly horror
- Easy to understand film due to its fantasy genre
- Genre is the same all over the world, makes it easily accessible
- Propps Theory (fairytale)
- Its genre is not important for messages therefore it is easier to accept worldwide


 Pans Labyrinth – Fantasy

-       Pans Labyrinth uses the fantasy genre as it is one that is accepted worldwide and can be viewed and understood by all audiences
-       Offers an opportunity for people to watch the film as a serious contextually strong piece of national cinema or as simply a fantasy from Ofelia’s point of view allowing it to be an international bestseller
-       The use of fantasy allows the messages of the film to be portrayed through the innocent eyes of a child, without the use of fantasy Ofelia would be facing up to real people rather than the monsters that she and we as the viewer sees
-       Allows us through the use of a fantasy genre to see how the war scars the children of Spain at the time